Opinion

More Carswell Concerns
John D Carswell - March 2005

Burgh BeautifuI - I joined the Steering Group because I thought Linlithgow had room for improvement to its looks. But I am finding it very frustrating: there seem to be so many hurdles to getting anything done and it is not for want of trying! Previous to the advent of Burgh Beautiful, there seems, in my view, to have been little creative work in recent years and little maintenance to what already existed. But in the meantime, everybody can make their own contribution by planting a tree in their garden and/or clearing up the litter as they find it!

Preston Road - In spite of thousands of pounds having been spent on 'traffic calming', I find it anything but restful to use the road, whether walking or driving. Inconsiderate stopping and parking of parents' cars continues to create a safety hazard. Would the introduction of mini-roundabouts at the ends of Priory Road and Braehead Road and lots of double yellow lines be an answer?

Schools - West Lothian Council continues to 'plan' the future shape of Linlithgow through development control based on a shortage of school places. This is surely a short-sighted approach which can only lead to dereliction, frustration and stagnation! All credit to the Civic Trust in its attempts to persuade the Council to take a more positive approach!

West Port - I could never agree with the general view of the Civic Trust some years ago that traffic lights be put up at the West Port. However, I just wish that one or two adjustments could be made to the new roundabout.

McCarthy & Stone Development, Blackness Road - I know that it is out of step with the Trust's thinking, but I continue to complain about the planning approval for the massive sheltered housing block on Blackness Road. The tower crane now dominating the sky-line should certainly help everyone understand how the semi-rural landscape will be destroyed for ever!

Retail Park - Again, with due respect to the Trust, the Stockbridge site certainly requires development and a retail park I think would be useful. The shops we have at present cannot provide everything and therefore one has to travel further afield. I believe that, if we can keep shoppers in the town, then the existing shops will benefit. (Though I do acknowledge that one or two may suffer.) The idea of a retail park does not conjure up good design but if the standard of the Sainburys store design can be repeated, plus landscaping of the burn, I would be happy.

John D Carswell - March 2005

Have Your Say!

If you want to express your own opinions on relevant issues, whether or not in response to John Carswell's articles, please send them to the Secretary or email them to newsletter@lct.org.uk.  We will include them here if we feel that they are relevant.

The opinions expressed here are those of the relevant authors and do not represent the views of Linlithgow Civic Trust.